Editorial: Promises – and jobs
“For 12 years in this country,” said Governor Dewey at Syracuse, “we have had an unmanageable surplus of promises, promises lightly made, sketchily kept, or openly violated.”
And President Roosevelt, at Chicago, boosted the output, at least equaling his own record for super promises: Sixty million productive post-war jobs; high wages and efficient production; government encouragement to growth of business, large and small; abiding faith in free enterprise and the profit system; trebled foreign trade; firm prosperity for farmers; America preserved as s land of action, of adventurous pioneering, of growing and building.
Such promises may win votes…
If enough voters have short memories.
Most of what the President said about how an abundance of post-war jobs can be created is thoroughly sound. Just as sound as it was when Mr. Dewey said it at Philadelphia nearly two months ago.
If we could forget Mr. Roosevelt’s record since he first became a promising presidential candidate, we’d hail his Chicago speech as the utterance of an economic statesman.
But there the record stands:
The many fervent promises of government frugality, followed by unprecedented government extravagance. The promises to curb bureaucracy, and bureaucracy enormously swollen in size and power. The promises to “stop the deficits,” and the deficits made an invariable annual event. The promises to preserve state rights, and authority centered in Washington as never before. The promises of jobs, and WPA used as a political machine.
When Mr. Roosevelt talks now of need for vast expansion of job-creating industrial capacity, we recall the long years when he practiced the mature economy philosophy, he stated in 1932 at San Francisco: “Our industrial plant is built; the problem just now is whether under existing conditions it is not overbuilt.”
When he proclaims belief that “private enterprise can give full employment,” we remember how Winston Churchill said in 1937:
The Washington administration has waged so ruthless a war on private enterprise that the United States… is actually leading the world back into the trough of depression.
When Mr. Roosevelt says he knows how to provide 60 million peacetime jobs, we remember that he had been President for seven peacetime years in 1940, and that then there were only 46 million jobs and almost 10 million people unemployed.
When he promises enlightened tax policies to encourage business expansion, we remember that the policies he would have to alter are his own policies, insisted upon by him although business showed that they were discouraging expansion.
We are for the things Mr. Roosevelt promised at Chicago. But we want them delivered, nor promised before election and forgotten afterward. “That’s why it’s time for a change.”