The Pittsburgh Press (April 3, 1941)
The truth about Italy: No. 1 –
GERMANS SEIZE ITALY TO AVERT SEPARATE PEACE
….
Mussolini completely defeated; Nazis spread hatred of U.S. among Italians
….
Editor’s note:
Here is the first absolutely uncensored and unrestrained story telling the exact situation in Italy today. It will be followed by at least seven other stories on the Italian crack-up.John T. Whitaker, noted Chicago Daily News Service correspondent, was expelled from Italy on Feb. 26. He had been in Rome continuously since June 1939, and also was with the Italian Army during the invasion of Ethiopia. He is acquainted with Mussolini, Ciano and other Italian leaders and was decorated by Italy after the Ethiopian war.
The Chicago Daily News Service is no longer attempting to maintain a Rome bureau in the face of Italian censorship. Therefore, now that Mr. Whitaker has reached a neutral country from which his dispatches are being cabled, he is free from any censorship and restraint – and thus becomes the first American newspaperman who can tell the full inside story of conditions in Italy.
By John T. Whitaker
Beyond the Italian frontier –
After 10 months of war, Italy’s defeat is complete, and to prevent the negotiation of a separate peace with Great Britain, the Germans have taken over control of the country. Italy’s regime, her armed forces, her internal police and much of her industry and agriculture already are under direct Nazi tutelage, and Benito Mussolini today is scarcely more than the gauleiter (district governor) of a conquered province.
This is the dramatic climax of 19 years of flamboyant Fascism. More than that, it is the tragic end of united Italy, which won its independence from Germanic domination only 80 years ago under the grandfather of the present king, who is sovereign now only by the grace of Adolf Hitler, which means in name alone.
How Mussolini took his country to war when it was utterly unprepared for that stern test, how this blunder disclosed the true nature of Fascism to the Italian people so that a whole nation lost its illusions and its will to fight, and finally how Hitler in eight swift weeks achieved a bloodless invasion of Italy, can now be told.
True story can now be told
Many an informed newspaperman in Rome knows that story but not one of the correspondents can tell it. They work there under a censorship that is intelligent and complete, fighting a daily battle in the wear of nerves, sick that they must withhold, so much of the truth but loyal to the editors and readers who want a man on the spot, however difficult it is to do this job.
Your correspondent can tell that story because he has been expelled from Italy and he writes free of censorship for the first time in a year. The authorities could cite no dispatch of mine from Italy as either inaccurate or misleading. They asked me to leave because my general tone was unfriendly to the Axis, and curiously enough because I had access to too many highly-placed Italians.
I have had four audiences with Mussolini and scores of conversations with his son-in-law, Count Ciano. I know Marshals Badoglio and Graziani.
But this seems a strange reason to ask a correspondent to go away. It is my personal opinion that the expulsion was ordered by the Germans. I have no concrete evidence of that, however, and it is only a surmise.
Germans threatened arrest
One month before my expulsion, the Germans already were pretty well in control of Rome, and more than one of them said in public places that they would have me arrested on some trumped-up charge of espionage if the Italian authorities would not expel me. It was obvious that the Germans wished to intimidate me into quitting Rome voluntarily, since the Italians, having had many proofs of my friendship for Italy, were reluctant to order my expulsion. The Germans rightly thought that I was no friend of Nazi Germany.
Uncensored articles on the defeat and occupation of Italy can be valuable to American readers if they achieve objectivity. In that spirit, I hope to describe the extent and manner of German infiltration; why the Italians are incapable of revolution; how Fascism as a system destroyed the efficiency of the armed forces; why Mussolini, after a brilliant series of success, is personally responsible for the tragedy; what happened in Libya; what happened in Greece; what happened in Ethiopia; the actual condition of the Italian people; why Fascism cannot work, and finally how the Germans mean to exploit their new province.
The most remarkable change that has come over Italy since the German entry is the country’s attitude toward the United States. The Nazi propaganda machine is deliberately teaching the Italians to mistrust and hate Americans. The newspapers now describe America as 40% Jewish, Roosevelt as an unscrupulous dictator with ambitions for world conquest, the American people as soulless Protestant money-grabbers, too cowardly to fight but opposed to the Axis out of a feeling of inferiority in the face of the countries that have produced Dante and Goethe, Wagner and Verdi.
This propaganda is beginning to have an effect because the essential argument is the face-saving idea that the Italians already would be enjoying peace and victory except for the Americans, who, though unwilling to fight themselves, help England in order to prolong the war and enrich themselves at the expense of an exhausted Europe.
The American consulates at Naples and Palermo were closed shortly after the Germans took control in Rome. That was significant, but Washington retaliated by closing two Italian consulates in America. More important than the expulsion of the consular officials was the fact that the Germans, with deliberate cynicism, persuaded the Italians that those officials were acting as spies.
Charge U.S. with spying
The Italian man in the street now believes that American consular officers signaled to British warships and planes for bombardments at Genoa and elsewhere, though the officers of his government, having taken down on phonograph discs every word or sound heard in those two consulates, know that the charge is false.
This lie is all the more brutal since the absence of any proper American intelligence service is often remarked upon by grateful Axis officers. Its mere mention brings guffaws of laughter from Italian as well as German officials.
After the closing of the consulates, a highly-placed officer in the Italian War Ministry said to me mockingly:
The American intelligence service must be the best in the world because neither we nor the Germans have ever been able to discover an American spy.
Early in the discussion of the Lend-Lease Bill, the Germans persuaded the Italians to undertake demonstrations against the United States. There was a mild and not very catching demonstration before the American consulate at Turin but the effort in Rome was called off.
I think they failed because the reaction of the Italian public in that period was so instantaneously opposed to such a demonstration that the German secret police thought better of the idea.
Americans are shadowed
All Rome knew of the demonstration to be held before the American Embassy five hours before the time fixed for the shouting. In that five hours, I heard the same reaction from at least 15 Italians:
When we are being beaten by the Greeks, are these madmen going to make us provoke America?
By now I think even that much common sense has been destroyed by the daily pricking of Goebbels’ poisoned pens and the careful preparation of Himmler’s black books.
No Italian officer or diplomat can see an American in Rome today without written permission and private citizens are told that they risk having their names written in the Gestapo black book. Most Americans, including your correspondent in his last month there, are followed by detectives wherever they go, and the servants of every American household are questioned daily on all visitors and their conversations.
Persons entering the American Embassy are stopped by detectives who ask for their papers and take down their names. All American telephones and the walls of the American Embassy and consulates are tapped with listening devices. The American ambassador consequently can have no private conversation with any Italian, and indeed it is very doubtful whether he can consult with Washington without having his coded cables broken.
Italy, in short, is German, and its public must be prepared for Hitler’s declaration of war, as Axis spokesmen sometimes say in Rome, if America begins to make aid to Britain decisive by convoying armaments directly to British ports.
Tomorrow’s story will tell how the Germans have made Mussolini virtually a prisoner and are running Italy.